Skip to main content

The Worst Cities for Porch Pirates During Black Friday and Christmas

Key takeaways

  • Nearly half (49%) of porch piracy victims are hit during the holiday season, and just over 1 in 6 (17%) had a package stolen around Black Friday.
  • 40% of Americans who had a package stolen say it disrupted their holiday gift-giving plans.
  • 54% of victims lost a package meant as a gift. Of those, 24% couldn't afford a replacement.
  • 12% say they're "addicted" to tracking their packages, and 43% admit to tracking their packages 2 or more times a day.
  • St. Louis ranks No. 1 overall for holiday-season property crime and package theft search interest, with a crime rate of 1,018 per 100K and 19.4 searches per 100K.
  • Memphis has the highest holiday-season property crime rate (1,057), followed by St. Louis (1,018), and Oakland (1,008).
Porch pirate stealing a package.
 

Few things dampen holiday cheer like a doorstep that's missing a package. As online orders pile up between Black Friday and Christmas, porch pirates know exactly when to strike. This year, 15% of Americans had a package stolen in the past year, and nearly half of those victims say it happened during the holiday season.

To see where the problem is biggest, we also ranked 92 U.S. cities on holiday-season property crime and search interest in package theft. Here's what porch piracy costs, how Americans are fighting back, and which cities top the list.

The real cost of porch piracy

Porch piracy is more than removing a package from a porch. It’s talking the gift that’s inside, and sometimes the plans that went with it.

 Infographic showing 15% of Americans had a package stolen in the past year and 49% of thefts happened during the holidays.
 

Fifteen percent of Americans had a package stolen in the past year. Among those victims, 49% said it happened during the holiday season, and 17% said it happened around Black Friday.

The financial hit is real, too. Thirty-seven percent of victims lost $100 or more, and 19% lost $200 or more. Amazon was the top retailer packages were stolen from, at 73%.

Because it's the season of giving, many of those packages were gifts. Fifty-four percent of victims lost a package that was meant as a gift, and 24% of them couldn't afford a replacement, up from 18% in our 2025 report. Overall, 40% of Americans who had a package stolen said it disrupted their holiday gift-giving plans, and among those who had a gift stolen, 35% spent $100 or more replacing it.

The emotional toll has grown. Sixty-three percent of consumers who had packages stolen felt anxious about future deliveries, compared with 47% last year. Forty-one percent had less trust in delivery services, and 26% felt disappointment during a holiday or gift occasion.

How are Americans avoiding porch piracy?

With so much on the line, shoppers are getting creative (and a little obsessive) about protecting their deliveries.

Infographic showing the strategies Americans use to protect their packages from porch pirates.
 

Ninety-two percent of Americans used at least one strategy to protect their packages. The most common was tracking alerts (76%), up from the 54% who told us last year they actively tracked packages from dispatch to delivery. Next was using a video doorbell or security camera to keep an eye on deliveries (43%).

For some, tracking has become a habit that's hard to break. Twelve percent said they're "addicted" to tracking their packages, and 43% admitted to tracking them two or more times a day. Forty-nine percent said how closely they track depends on the item.

Fear of theft is also changing how people shop. Forty-five percent changed their shopping habits because of the risk, most often by avoiding expensive items online (20%) or buying more in stores (16%). Scammers are taking advantage, too: 47% received a package-related scam message. People are also open to smarter solutions. Forty-two percent would pay more each month for AI package alerts, with a median of $10 more per month.

The worst cities for property crime during the holidays

Where you live matters, too. To find the cities where porch pirates have the most opportunity, we combined holiday-season property crime with search interest in package theft across 92 U.S. cities.

Infographic showing where holiday property crime and package theft worry run highest and lowest across U.S. cities.
 

St. Louis ranked No. 1 overall, with a holiday-season property crime rate of 1,018 per 100K residents and 19.4 package theft searches per 100K. Atlanta had the highest rate of package theft searches (20.9 per 100K residents). Memphis had the highest holiday-season property crime rate at 1,057 per 100K, followed by St. Louis (1,018) and Oakland (1,008). On the other end, McKinney had the lowest rate (141), followed by Gilbert (173) and Frisco (188).

Staying a step ahead of porch pirates this holiday season

Porch piracy hits hardest when it takes a gift meant for someone you love, and the anxiety it leaves behind can last well past December. Whether you live in a top-10 city or not, the best defense is planning ahead. Track your deliveries, ship to a place where someone can receive them, and keep an eye on your porch while the packages pile up. A little preparation now can keep the season about the gifts, not the ones that went missing.

Methodology

We surveyed 1,000 Americans in October 2026 to explore experiences with porch piracy. Results reflect self-reported data and may be subject to response bias.

To identify the worst cities for porch piracy during the holidays, we combined two measures for 92 U.S. cities: police-reported property crime and search interest in package theft. Both are limited to November and December.

Crime

For each city, we took the monthly property-crime rate per 100,000 residents, averaged the November rates and the December rates separately across 2020 to 2025, then added the two averages. Only the overall property-crime figure was used. Months with unreliable source data (zero or non-reporting, an annual total booked in one month, more than twice the city's own baseline, or less than half of it) were removed. If either month of a year was flagged, both months of that year were removed.

Search

We summed Google search volume for "stolen package," "missing package," and "porch pirate," averaged the monthly totals across November and December of 2023 to 2025, then divided by city population and multiplied by 100,000.

Scoring and weights

Each metric was scaled 0–100 across the 92 cities using the formula (value − lowest) ÷ (highest − lowest) × 100. The composite score is weighted 50% crime and 50% search, and cities are ranked on it.

Metaranking limitations

  • Crime data is police-reported property crime and does not measure package theft specifically.
  • Agencies report differently. Screening removed obvious reporting errors but can't catch every inconsistency.
  • Search volume measures interest, not victimization.

Fair use statement

We welcome the use of this information for noncommercial purposes. If you share our findings, please include a link to this page to credit Vivint and provide access to the full report.

Get a free quote today.

A Vivint Smart Home Pro will contact you within 24 hours. Or skip the form and call now: 844.481.8630.

By clicking "Start Your Quote", you agree by electronic signature to:
1. The Electronic Disclosure Consent;
2. Receive recurring marketing communications from Vivint at the telephone number and email address you provide on this form, including calls, texts, emails, and voice messages delivered using automated dialing systems, prerecorded or artificial voice, and AI-enabled technologies (consent not required to make a purchase; reply “STOP” to opt-out of texts or “HELP” for help); and
3. Vivint's Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.

Related content
  • Home Automation Services for Smarter Living

    Control Security Equipment & Smart Home Devices with a Vivint Home Automation System. Call 855.747.4838 for More Information about our Award Winning 24/7 Smart Home Automation Systems.

  • Security Camera Systems

    Vivint's Home Security Cameras System allows you to keep an eye on your home via Indoor Security Camera & Outdoor Security Cameras all Accessible through Vivint’s App. Call 855-743-7375 to ...

  • Vivint Services

    Home Security Services & Business Alarm Monitoring with Professional Installation with any Vivint Package Call 844.395.9444 to Learn More about our Award-Winning 24/7 Monitoring Services

*Offer Terms & Conditions

All offers are subject to availability and may not be available in all states, provinces, or zip codes. Taxes and additional fees may apply.

HomeProtect Offer Terms

Vivint’s standard HomeProtect package includes 1 Vivint Security Hub, 3 Vivint Door & Window Sensors, 1 Vivint Motion Sensor, 1 Vivint Keypad, and 1 Vivint yard sign. The HomeProtect equipment package is regularly priced at $349.99, with professional installation priced at $199 and Vivint system monitoring at $29.99/mo., unless otherwise advertised. Offer for new Vivint customers only.

HomeProtect Pro Offer Terms

The HomeProtect Pro Offer is available to new and existing Vivint customers and requires a minimum $749.99 expenditure on equipment (after discounts), professional installation and execution of a Vivint services agreement. Monthly service fees vary based on the products and services you select. HomeProtect system purchases and reactivations of previously-installed systems are not eligible for this offer.

Financing Options

Financing for equipment purchases is subject to credit approval by one of Vivint’s third-party financing partners. Qualified customers may finance at 0% APR for up to 60 months, with terms varying by offer. Financing requires a separate agreement with the financing partner. Month-to-month service agreements are available when equipment is purchased upfront.

Vivint Systems & Services

System can support multiple cameras, subject to sufficient WiFi speeds. Without a Vivint services plan, product and system functionality is limited (including loss of remote connectivity). Contact a Vivint representative for complete equipment, services, and pricing details. Products and services in Louisiana provided by Vivint Louisiana Commercial Certificate #58280. See Vivint license numbers here. Click here for full terms of service.